Monthly Membership vs Paying Per Pickup — Which Is Better?
Choosing between monthly membership and per-pickup pricing depends on your return frequency. Here's how to determine which is better for you.
The Comparison
Per-Pickup Pricing
The Cost:
- $20-25 per pickup
- Pay as you go
Annual (12 returns):
- $240-300
- Annual cost
Best For:
- Occasional returns
- 1-2 returns/month
- Low volume
Monthly Membership
The Cost:
- $30-50/month
- $360-600/year
- Flat rate
Best For:
- Frequent returns
- 3+ returns/month
- High volume
The Break-Even Point
The Math
Membership Cost:
- $40/month = $480/year
Per-Pickup Cost:
- $22 per pickup
Break-Even:
- $480 ÷ $22 = 22 returns/year
- 1.8 returns/month
If you return 2+ times/month, membership is better
Making the Decision
Calculate Your Usage
Step 1: Count Returns
- How many per month?
- Determine frequency
Step 2: Calculate Annual Cost
- Per-pickup: Returns × $22
- Membership: $40 × 12
- Compare
Step 3: Choose
- Which is cheaper?
- Make decision
The Bottom Line
Monthly membership is better for frequent returners (2+ returns/month). Per-pickup is better for occasional returners (1 return/month).
Calculate your return frequency to determine which is better for you.
Ready to see which is better? Check Returnful's pricing and calculate your savings.
Not sure which to choose? Text us at 469-790-7579 for personalized guidance!
Written by
Returnful Team
Part of the Returnful team, helping DFW residents save time on their online returns with same-day pickup service.
Get Return Tips in Your Inbox
Weekly tips to save time on returns. No spam.

