FedEx vs UPS for returns — which one is more reliable?

When you need to return something, the retailer often gives you a choice between FedEx and UPS. Which one should you choose? This comprehensive comparison covers reliability, speed, tracking, drop-off locations, customer service, and overall experience to help you make the best choice for your returns.

Overall Reliability Comparison

UPS Reliability

Strengths:

• Generally very reliable
• Extensive network
• Good tracking
• Consistent service
• Well-established

Weaknesses:

• Can have delays during peak seasons
• Some locations have long lines
• Occasional service issues

Reliability rating: 4.5/5

FedEx Reliability

Strengths:

• Very reliable
• Good network coverage
• Consistent delivery
• Professional service
• Well-established

Weaknesses:

• Can have delays during peak seasons
• Some service variations by type
• Occasional issues

Reliability rating: 4.5/5

Verdict

Both are very reliable for returns. UPS and FedEx both have excellent reliability records, and the difference is often minimal. Your choice may depend more on convenience (drop-off locations, hours) than reliability.

Speed Comparison

Transit Times

UPS:

• Ground: 1-5 business days
• Express: 1-3 business days
• Overnight: Next business day
• Generally consistent

FedEx:

• Ground: 1-5 business days
• Express: 1-3 business days
• Overnight: Next business day
• Generally consistent

For Returns Specifically

Both carriers:

• Return transit times similar
• Depends on distance
• Usually 2-4 business days average
• Both handle returns efficiently

Verdict: Essentially equal for return speed. Both are fast and reliable.

Tracking Comparison

UPS Tracking

Features:

• Detailed tracking updates
• Real-time location
• Delivery confirmation
• Email/text notifications
• Mobile app

Quality: Excellent tracking, frequent updates, easy to use.

FedEx Tracking

Features:

• Detailed tracking updates
• Real-time location
• Delivery confirmation
• Email/text notifications
• Mobile app

Quality: Excellent tracking, frequent updates, easy to use.

Verdict

Both offer excellent tracking. The difference is minimal. Both provide detailed updates, notifications, and easy-to-use tracking systems.

Drop-Off Location Comparison

UPS Drop-Off Locations

Options:

• UPS Stores (thousands of locations)
• UPS Customer Centers
• UPS Access Points (CVS, Michaels, etc.)
• UPS Drop Boxes
• Authorized shipping outlets

Coverage: Extensive, especially in urban and suburban areas.

Convenience: Very convenient, many locations, good hours.

FedEx Drop-Off Locations

Options:

• FedEx Office locations
• FedEx Ship Centers
• FedEx Drop Boxes
• Authorized shipping locations
• Some retail partners

Coverage: Good, but may have fewer locations than UPS in some areas.

Convenience: Convenient, but may require slightly longer drive in some areas.

Location Availability

Urban areas: Both have good coverage Suburban areas: Both have good coverage, UPS may have slight edge Rural areas: Both may have limited options, varies by location

Verdict: UPS has slight edge in number of locations, but both are convenient for most people.

Wait Times at Drop-Off Locations

UPS Store Wait Times

Average: 15-25 minutes Peak times: 25-40 minutes Off-peak: 5-10 minutes

Factors:

• Location popularity
• Time of day
• Day of week
• Staffing levels

FedEx Office Wait Times

Average: 10-20 minutes Peak times: 20-35 minutes Off-peak: 5-10 minutes

Factors:

• Location popularity
• Time of day
• Day of week
• Staffing levels

Verdict

FedEx may have slightly shorter waits on average, but it varies significantly by location and time. Both can have long waits during peak times.

Customer Service Comparison

UPS Customer Service

Availability:

• Phone support
• Online chat
• Email support
• Social media support

Quality: Generally good, can have wait times during peak periods.

Response time: Usually responsive, may vary by issue complexity.

FedEx Customer Service

Availability:

• Phone support
• Online chat
• Email support
• Social media support

Quality: Generally good, professional service.

Response time: Usually responsive, may vary by issue complexity.

Verdict

Both offer good customer service. The difference is minimal, and both are generally helpful and professional.

Cost Comparison (For Paid Returns)

UPS Costs

If you're paying:

• Ground: Similar to FedEx
• Express: Similar to FedEx
• Overnight: Similar to FedEx
• Generally competitive

FedEx Costs

If you're paying:

• Ground: Similar to UPS
• Express: Similar to UPS
• Overnight: Similar to UPS
• Generally competitive

For Returns

Most returns are prepaid by the retailer, so cost isn't usually a factor. When you do pay, both are similarly priced.

Verdict: Essentially equal for return costs (usually prepaid anyway).

Package Handling

UPS Package Handling

Reputation: Generally good

• Professional handling
• Careful with packages
• Good packaging support
• Occasional issues (rare)

FedEx Package Handling

Reputation: Generally good

• Professional handling
• Careful with packages
• Good packaging support
• Occasional issues (rare)

Verdict

Both handle packages well. The difference is minimal, and both are generally careful with returns.

Peak Season Performance

Holiday Season

UPS:

• Can have delays during peak
• Increased volume
• May take longer
• Generally handles well

FedEx:

• Can have delays during peak
• Increased volume
• May take longer
• Generally handles well

Verdict

Both can have delays during peak seasons, but both generally handle increased volume well. The difference is minimal.

Special Services

UPS Special Services

Options:

• Signature required
• Insurance
• Special handling
• Various service levels

FedEx Special Services

Options:

• Signature required
• Insurance
• Special handling
• Various service levels

Verdict

Both offer similar special services. For standard returns, you typically don't need these.

Mobile App Comparison

UPS Mobile App

Features:

• Tracking
• Drop-off location finder
• Schedule pickup
• Manage shipments
• Good user experience

FedEx Mobile App

Features:

• Tracking
• Drop-off location finder
• Schedule pickup
• Manage shipments
• Good user experience

Verdict

Both have good mobile apps. The difference is minimal, and both are user-friendly.

Which Should You Choose?

Choose UPS If

• More drop-off locations near you
• Prefer UPS Store experience
• Retailer recommends UPS
• Have UPS account or preference
• UPS Access Points are convenient

Choose FedEx If

• FedEx Office is more convenient
• Shorter wait times at FedEx locations
• Retailer recommends FedEx
• Have FedEx account or preference
• FedEx locations are closer

General Recommendation

For most people: Choose based on convenience (which location is closer/easier) rather than reliability, as both are very reliable.

If locations are equal: Either choice is fine—both are excellent for returns.

Real-World Experience

Common Feedback

UPS:

• Generally positive
• Reliable service
• Good tracking
• Long lines at some locations
• Convenient locations

FedEx:

• Generally positive
• Reliable service
• Good tracking
• Professional service
• Good locations

Both Are Good Choices

Reality: Most people have good experiences with both. The choice often comes down to personal preference or convenience.

Tips for Best Experience

Regardless of Carrier

1. Package securely: Proper packaging prevents issues
2. Track your return: Monitor progress
3. Drop off promptly: Don't wait
4. Keep documentation: Save receipts and tracking
5. Choose convenient location: Save time

For UPS

• Go at off-peak times: Avoid long lines
• Use Access Points: Often faster
• Use drop boxes: For prepaid packages
• Track online: Easy tracking system

For FedEx

• Go at off-peak times: Avoid long lines
• Use drop boxes: For prepaid packages
• Track online: Easy tracking system
• Check location hours: Before going

The Bottom Line

Both FedEx and UPS are very reliable for returns. The difference in reliability is minimal, and both offer excellent service. Your choice should be based on:

1. Convenience: Which has locations closer to you?
2. Wait times: Which has shorter lines at convenient times?
3. Retailer recommendation: What does the retailer suggest?
4. Personal preference: Do you have a preference?

For most returns, either carrier will work well. Both are reliable, fast, and offer good tracking. Choose based on what's most convenient for you.

---

Don't want to choose? Returnful handles returns through any carrier, so you don't have to decide. Learn more or text us at 469-790-7579.